The judge refused an application for permanent name suppression, however the man’s lawyer has been given leave to appeal.
In the Auckland District Court this month, the jury heard how it has been almost a year since rising tensions, involving windows overlooking the complainant’s property and a screen overshadowing the investment manager’s garden, blew up.
On the evening of Good Friday last year, the investment manager had been playing the macarena loudly and repeatedly outside and the neighbor sprayed the speaker with a hose. This prompted the investment manager to jump the fence and the two men began a physical fight, with the complainant’s wife spraying them both with a hose.
The investment manager landed blows to the neighbor’s head, but the complainant reciprocated and split the investment manager’s eye also.
After an hour of deliberations the jury found the investment manager not guilty of causing grievous bodily harm with intent to injure.
The day after the decision, defense lawyer, John Munro, applied for his client’s interim name suppression to be made permanent.
In rejecting the application, Judge Evangelos Thomas said the investment manager’s firm had temporarily suspended him and taken no disciplinary action pending the outcome of the case. He said an internal employment process would continue regardless of publication of the man’s name, and any suggestion he could lose his job was entirely speculative. Likewise, any suggestion client’s of the firm would leave was also speculative.
